#سؤال: بداء چیست و آیا قائلین به بداء از تشیع خارجند؟ پاسخ استاد میلانی @Hmilani

Channel
حسن میلانی
@Hmilani
On this record: Growth · Engagement · What this channel posts · Posts · Citations · Telegram's recommendations · Cite this entry
4,603subscribers
+33 since we began measuring on 6 August 2026
Risers and fallers across the register · movement among entries of 3,162–10,000.
Register entry
| Telegram ID | -1001081454948 |
|---|---|
| Type | Channel |
| Username | @Hmilani |
| Created | Between 1 September 2016 and 30 September 2017 — estimated from Telegram’s id allocation, not measured. How this range is calculated. |
| First recorded | 6 August 2026 |
| Last confirmed live | 5 September 2026 |
| Measurements held | 11 |
| Confirmed unchanged | 1 time, most recently 5 September 2026 |
| On Telegram | t.me/Hmilani |
Growth
| Measured (UTC) | Subscribers | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 5 Sept 2026, 22:21 | 4,603 | +6 |
| 1 Sept 2026, 16:16 | 4,597 | -2 |
| 29 Aug 2026, 19:36 | 4,599 | +6 |
| 26 Aug 2026, 17:36 | 4,593 | -2 |
| 23 Aug 2026, 12:08 | 4,595 | -2 |
| 19 Aug 2026, 14:52 | 4,597 | +4 |
| 16 Aug 2026, 18:03 | 4,593 | +14 |
| 12 Aug 2026, 21:53 | 4,579 | +5 |
| 9 Aug 2026, 13:01 | 4,574 | +4 |
| 6 Aug 2026, 04:02 | 4,570 | no change |
| 6 Aug 2026, 00:32 | 4,570 | first reading |
Engagement
22 posts held, back to 16 May 2026 — the reader has not yet reached the start of this channel’s public history, so older posts may sit further back, unread. Read across 7 pages of Telegram’s post history, 20 posts per page.
- ERR · 30 days
- 11.6%
- avg views ÷ 4,603 subscribers
- Avg views / post
- 532
- 2 posts measured
- Reaction rate
- —
- this channel exposes no reaction counts
- Posts in window
- 2
- of 22 held
ERR is average views per post over the last 30 days divided by subscribers, the definition TGStat uses, so this figure is comparable with the one you will see elsewhere. It falls structurally as a channel grows: a high ERR on a small channel and a low one on a large channel describe reach mathematics, not quality. We publish the figure and the sample it came from and pass no verdict on it.
ER is defined industry-wide as (forwards + reactions + comments) ÷ views — note the denominator is views, not subscribers. Telegram’s public web preview carries views and reactions but not forward or comment counts, so the reaction rate above is the reactions term only and is therefore a floor: the true ER for this channel is higher by an amount we have not measured and will not estimate.
| Window | Rolling 30 days · latest post in window 10 August 2026 |
|---|---|
| Posts held | 22 (16 May 2026 – 10 August 2026) |
| Views total | 1,064 |
| Reactions total | — |
| Forwards / comments | not exposed by the public surface — not measured, not estimated |
| Readings taken | 12 Aug 2026, 06:33 UTC |
Views are a single reading per post, taken at the time above. A post published in the last day or two is still accumulating views, which pulls the 30-day average down slightly. That is a property of the standard definition rather than a fault in it, so we keep the definition rather than “correcting” the number into something nobody can reproduce.
Precision. Telegram publishes view counts on its public widget in short form — 8.12K, 3.7M — so any reading at or above 1,000 reaches us rounded to three significant figures, and only counts below 1,000 are exact. Averages and rates derived from them are shown to the same precision rather than to the unit: a figure like 3,701,250 would assert digits nobody measured.
Reaction counts are published per emoji and rounded the same way, so a total below 1,000 is exact and a larger one is a sum that may carry a rounded component from each emoji above 1,000. Because it is a sum, it does not look rounded — read a large reaction total as three significant figures per contributing emoji rather than as the figure it prints.
What this channel posts
- Video runtime
- 13m 50s
- Average length
- 3m 28s
Measured directly from 4 videos with a duration reading, out of the posts we hold for this channel — not this channel’s whole posting history, only the sample this register has actually read. An exact reading to the second, taken from the post itself rather than from Telegram’s own rounded chrome, so it carries no ≈ mark.
Recent posts
🎥 #کلیپ بهترین و کاملترین و عقلانیترین پاسخها همیشه در کلام معصومین علیهم السلام پیدا میشود. ادعای تفاوت ظرفیتها بین کافر و مؤمن، و نیز نظام علی و معلولی بیارزشترین پاسخهایی است که فلاسفه و عرفا ارائه میدهند. @Hmilani
دروس و دورههای استاد میلانی در سایت آکادمی امام صادق علیه السلام https://imamsadiq.ac/fa/@h-milani بعد از ثبت نام، دسترسی به دروس رایگان است. @Hmilani
#سؤال: پاسخ استاد میلانی به شبهاتی که اخیرا برخی به شعائر حسینی کردهاند؛ 🔹اول کسی که قرنها قبل از عاشورا به پیشواز آن رفت خود خداوند متعال بود. غلو در عزاداری| پیرغلام| نوکری امام حسین #بازنشر @Hmilani
🎥 #کلیپ حدیثی زیبا از امام حسین علیه السلام درباره مولا امیرالمؤمنین صلوات الله علیه و سفارش امیرالمؤمنین علیه السلام به مردم درباره امام حسن و امام حسین علیهما السلام ودیعه و امانت پیامبر | سوال روز قیامت سقیفه | عاشورا @Hmilani
كيفية تصور خالق بلا زمان ولا مكان #التنبيهات_العقائدية ٦٤ #نقد_الفلسفة #شيء_بخلاف_الأشياء #الزمان #المكان #العقل 📚فراتر از عرفان، ص٣٩١ @mahadalmajlesi لمتابعة دروس ومطالب الأستاذ بالعربية👇 #الدروس_بالعربیة @Hmilani
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم واحسیناه ، وامظلوماه صلی الله علیک یارسول الله وعلی أهل بیتک المظلومین سيدي عظّم الله لك الأجور بمصابك الجلل في فلذة كبدك الحسين الشهيد المذبوح بكربلاء صلواة الله عليه وساعدالله قلب نجلك الطاهر إمام زماننا صاحب الأمر والزمان في مصيبة جده المظلوم أبي عبدالله الحسين صلوةالله عليهم أجمعين مجلس عزاداري حضرت سيدالشهداء عليه السلام از اول محرم تا روز هشتم محرم : صبحها : از ساعت ۷ تا ۹ صبح روز تاس…
#یا_عالی_بحق_علی_علیه_السلام_عجل_لولیک_الفرج #اللهم_العن_الجبت_و_الطاغوت #استاد_شیخ_حسن_میلانی #انوارالهدی_کاشان زمان: سه شنبه ۱۹ خرداد ماه 🔹۱۹ الی ۲۰:۱۵، توسل و نماز جماعت 🔹۲۰:۱۵ الی ۲۱:۱۵، بحث خداشناسی 🔹۲۱:۳۰ الی ۲۲:۳۰، بحث امام شناسی (با موضوع شرح زیارت جامعه کبیره) آدرس: شهرک امیرالمومنین علیه السلام، ابتدای ذوالفقار ۴۱ " برادران " پخش زنده در ایتا: @Hmilani @Anvarolhodakashan 🔘 تلگرام / ایتا / روبیکا: @anv…
#سؤال: در روایاتی که میگوید اولی و دومی در گناه اولین و آخرین فرد سهیم هستند، برای آخرین فرد میتوان تصور سهیم بودن اولی را کرد، ولی نقش اولی و دومی در گناهان اولین فرد چیست؟ آنها که در زمانِ گناهِ اولین فرد وجود نداشتند. ✍پاسخ: مقصود میتواند اولین و آخرین فرد از امت رسول خدا باشد نه اولین فردِ گنهکار در امتهای پیشین و اگر منظور اولین فرد گنهکار بطور کلی باشد میتوان اینگونه معنا کرد که اولی و دومی در عالم ذر جرأ…
پخش آنلاینِ جلسات نقدِ کتاب درسی فلسفه دبیرستان شنبهها، ساعت ۲۰:۳۰ ایتا https://eitaa.com/Hmilani
نقد و بررسی کتاب درسیِ فلسفه دبیرستان استاد میلانی | جلسه۴ 0:32 "اشتراک مفهوم و وحدت حقیقت وجود" 04:39 نقد ادعای کتاب 10:33 نقد جوابهای کتاب اشکال اول: وجود و ماهیت از معقولات ثانیه هستند و در خارج وجود عینی ندارند 14:38 اشکال دوم: صدق ماهیت بر چند مصداق؛ همه مباحث قبلی را میتوان برعکس نیز مطرح کرد 20:26 نه وجود منشاء کثرت است و نه ماهیت 24:09 حق آن است که نه ماهیت کثرت دارد و نه وجود؛ خود اینها منشاء کثرت نیستند…
مخمس غدیریه استاد میلانی شب دراز هجر را نموده نک سپیده دم دمیده در غدیر خم سرو و چمن قدم قدم گیسوی حوری از نسیم او گرفته پیچ و خم شبنم شوق کوی او نشانده دیده را به نم قمری زار را بگو نوحه مکن که رفت غم ........................ الحمد لله الذي جعلنا من المتمسکین بولایة أمیر المؤمنین والأئمة علیهم السلام @Hmilani
Showing the 12 most recent of 22 posts we hold for @Hmilani. View and reaction counts are the latest single reading for each post, not a live figure, and a recent post is still accumulating both. A view count marked ≈ was rounded by Telegram before we ever saw it — t.me prints views in full below 1,000 and to three significant figures above, so ≈1,200,000 means somewhere between 1,150,000 and 1,249,999. Unmarked counts are exact. Text is reproduced from the public post preview and truncated for length.
Forward network
Republished by
Channels on the register that have forwarded this channel's posts into their own feed.
@Bookcafe · 1,3682 postsنقد كمال الحيدري
@almajlesi110 · 6291 postجلسه انوارالهدی کاشان
@Anvarolhodakashan · 1751 postebnecirin - ابن سیرین
@ebnecirin · 1001 postفاروق اعظم امیرالمومنین ع است
@farooqir · 3331 postنه به زندگی شرقی و غربی - وَ لَا يَسْلُكُوا مَسَالِكَ أَعْدَائِي
@islam110313 · 2191 postالنَبأ العَظیم
@nabaolazimm · 7761 post
Republishes
Channels on the register whose posts this channel has forwarded.
Built only from forwarded posts we have actually read, on both sides. Coverage is early and deliberately incomplete: a missing link means we have not read the post that would prove it, never that the relationship does not exist. Counts are distinct forwarded posts observed, so they only ever go up as we read more.
Mentions
Named by 11 registered channels — every channel on the register whose own posts have named this one, by its current username or any other username it currently holds, merged from two separately captured readings of the same fact so a namer caught by only one of them is not missed and a namer both caught is not counted twice. A username this channel has since dropped is not matched — that handle may belong to someone else now, and crediting today’s namer to yesterday’s owner would misattribute it.
Named by
Channels on the register whose posts name this channel's handle.
@ketab_14 · 6513 postsالأزهار الأَرَجيّة
@alazhar1441 · 1992 postsBookcafe | كافه كتاب
@Bookcafe · 1,3682 postsنقد فلسفه = دفاع از عقلانیت
@Aghlyavaran · 1,0951 postنقد كمال الحيدري
@almajlesi110 · 6291 postجلسه انوارالهدی کاشان
@Anvarolhodakashan · 1751 postebnecirin - ابن سیرین
@ebnecirin · 1001 postفاروق اعظم امیرالمومنین ع است
@farooqir · 3331 postنه به زندگی شرقی و غربی - وَ لَا يَسْلُكُوا مَسَالِكَ أَعْدَائِي
@islam110313 · 2191 postالنَبأ العَظیم
@nabaolazimm · 7761 postنقد و بررسی مکتب تفکیک
@tafkik · 2,5021 post
Names
Channels on the register whose handles appear in this channel's posts.
A mention is a weaker signal than a forward and is counted separately for that reason — naming a channel is not republishing it, and a handle in a post body is easy to place deliberately. The post counts beside each row below are distinct posts in which the handle appeared, from posts we have read on both sides — the “Named by N registered channels” figure above is a different count, of distinct NAMING CHANNELS rather than posts, and is not the sum of the rows under it.
Appears in Telegram’s recommendations for other channels
The reverse of the list above, and a different kind of signal. This does not require this channel to have ever been asked about directly — each row below is a channel we DID ask Telegram about, whose Telegram-generated list happened to include this one. A channel can appear here with an empty list above it, because being named by someone else’s query is independent of having been queried itself.
@hoqoq99 · 35,636
Telegram ranks this channel #69 of 77 here — alongside 76 others — read 2 September 2026
@bankehoghogh · 46,532
Telegram ranks this channel #75 of 81 here — alongside 80 others — read 27 August 2026
This channel appears in 2 seed channels' Telegram-generated recommendation lists in total. Each is Telegram’s list for THAT channel, not this one — see how this is measured.
Cite this entry
A live page changes as we take new readings, so a citation should name the measurement it is based on, not just the URL. The line below cites the subscriber count as measured 5 September 2026 — this entry's latest reading, not the date you are reading this.
“حسن میلانی” (@Hmilani), 4,603 subscribers as measured 5 September 2026. Telegram Register, tgregister.com/channel/Hmilani.
Full measurement history, CC BY 4.0. Every reading this register holds for this entry, not just the latest one, as a dated, downloadable record: CSV · JSON. Free to use with attribution to tgregister.com. Each file carries its own generation timestamp, which is the figure to cite for exactly when the data was retrieved.